Version Control
Dexter Palmer
Literary Science Fiction
Literary SciFi
Version Control is a book I thoroughly enjoyed—more so for Mr. Palmer’s exceptional literary writing than as science fiction. I picked this up at the strong recommendation of fellow wordpress blogger Bart, while discussing time travel and sci-fi books in general. I am grateful that I did. His detailed five star review is worth a read.
What wonderful writing!
What sticks with me as I think about this book now—a couple of months after reading it—is the fluid writing style: it entices, and beguiles you into enjoying long passages with or without dialogue, which are often tangential to the main story and often only move the story a wee bit. Some have described Mr. Palmer’s style as verbose. I wouldn’t. This makes the book quite long by most standards: ~500 pages at small font in my copy, but unlike some really long books, I was never ever left counting the pages to the end. And that’s the magic of Mr. Palmer’s writing. His isn’t the prose of Ian McEwan or Kazuo Ishiguro or the general Booker prize winner. It feels casual and effortless, yet equally satisfying to read. I envy him for that talent.
More literature than sci-fi
The book is set in the near future: one where AI has infiltrated several facets of daily life from self driving cars to education to clothes fitting. All of these feel well within our own reach in a few years, given the current trajectory of technology and ML. The true sci-fi aspect of the story is the causality violation device that some of the scientist characters in the story are working on and “they would greatly prefer it if you didn’t call it a time machine”.
Not all the main characters are scientists but they are all equally well developed at the adept hands of Mr. Palmer—a feature commonly found wanting in many sci-fi books. But that’s because Mr. Palmer is a student of literature rather than Science.
And this shows throughout the book, and particularly so at the end. The Mechanics of time travel (or causality violation) are never fully clear even after careful reading—and I’m someone who will read parts of books several times just so the premise is clear to me (e.g. see my explainer for Recursion, another time travel book). Unfortunately what is possible and is not is never revealed leaving the scientific premise dissatisfying—my only nit with this book.
Time Travel as a backdrop
But that’s when I realized that time travel is merely the construct to cover a broad array of subjects including relationships, fidelity, race, the scientific process, career, data privacy, love, sacrifice, and more. These many and diverse themes are exquisitely woven into the story of Rebecca Wright and Philip Steiner, and their friends and family. There is a palpable melancholy and wistfulness throughout—stemming from tragic events and unfulfilled desires of the characters—which might be off putting for some, but part of the appeal in my opinion.
Overall: Rewarding read
This novel delivered in spades on what I look for in a book: a well written, speculative, thought provoking story from someone who is deeply in touch with humanity. One of my best reads of 2020. It’s a mystery to me this book doesn’t have a four star or greater overall rating on Goodreads.
5 thoughts on “Version Control”
I’m glad you enjoyed the book so much! It was one of my favorite reads that year as well. The problem for this book might be that it is hard to market: too literary for some of the SF fans, and too SF for some regular literature readers. I do think the AI part might be prophetic, and the political angles are good too, but never preachy.
We’ll see if the Goodreads readers will come up with some answers.
That’s a good characterization of the book’s challenges—straddling two genres. Thanks again for pointing me to the book. Hope you’re doing well and your 2021 reading has gotten off to a good start.
I’m reading Nova Swing by Harrison atm, first really good read of the year. Have a good one too!
Pingback: Bewilderment – Starvind astrophotography
Pingback: Sea of Tranquility – Starvind astrophotography